Kegels Aren’t Always the Answer—Maybe It’s Time for a Timeout

If you've ever leaked urine when you coughed, sneezed, or exercised, chances are someone has told you to "just do your Kegels." It's one of the most common pieces of advice given for pelvic floor issues—but it's not always the right advice. In fact, for some people, doing more Kegels can actually make their symptoms worse.
The truth is that your pelvic floor isn't just about strength. It's about
strength, coordination, flexibility, endurance, and the ability to both contract
and relax. Just like any other muscle in your body, your pelvic floor needs balance.
What are Kegels?
Kegels are exercises that involve consciously contracting and relaxing your pelvic floor muscles. They can be incredibly effective for some people, particularly those with weakness contributing to bladder leakage or reduced pelvic floor support. However, they're not a one-size-fits-all solution.
Before starting any pelvic floor exercise program, it's important to know why you're experiencing symptoms in the first place.
When should you stop doing Kegels?
If you're experiencing any of the following symptoms, it's worth seeing a pelvic floor physiotherapist before continuing with strengthening exercises.
1. You have pelvic pain
Pain is not usually a sign that a muscle simply needs to get stronger. Many people with pelvic pain actually have
overactive or tight pelvic floor muscles that struggle to relax. Adding repeated contractions may increase muscle tension rather than improve symptoms.
2. Sex is painful
Pain during intercourse can have many causes, but an overactive pelvic floor is one possible contributor. If your pelvic floor muscles are already working overtime, strengthening exercises alone are unlikely to address the underlying issue. Treatment often focuses on helping the muscles learn to relax, lengthen and coordinate appropriately.
3. You're constantly rushing to the toilet
Urgency doesn't always mean your pelvic floor is weak. Sometimes the muscles surrounding the bladder and urethra remain tense, creating altered bladder signals or poor coordination. A comprehensive assessment can help determine what's driving your symptoms.
4. You struggle to empty your bladder or bowels
Your pelvic floor needs to relax to allow urine and stool to pass.
If these muscles don't let go properly, you may experience:
- constipation
- straining
- incomplete emptying
- difficulty starting your urine stream.
Doing repeated Kegels without addressing relaxation may not be helpful.
5. You feel tight "down there"
Some people describe:
- a feeling of pressure
- tightness
- aching
- muscle spasms
- difficulty inserting tampons
- discomfort during pelvic examinations.
These symptoms may suggest your pelvic floor is overactive rather than weak.
6. Your symptoms are getting worse
If you've been faithfully doing Kegels for weeks or months but your symptoms haven't improved—or they've become worse—it's time to stop guessing.
Pelvic floor dysfunction is complex, and not every problem is solved with strengthening exercises.
Isn't a stronger pelvic floor always better?
Not necessarily. Imagine someone whose shoulders are permanently shrugged up towards their ears. Would giving them shoulder shrugs all day solve the problem? Probably not. Instead, you'd want to help those muscles relax, move normally and regain healthy function. The pelvic floor works the same way.
A muscle that's constantly switched on isn't necessarily a strong muscle—it's often a muscle that's working inefficiently.
Healthy pelvic floor muscles need to:
- contract when needed
- relax fully
- respond quickly
- generate appropriate force
- coordinate with your breathing and core muscles.
So who actually needs Kegels?
Kegels may be recommended for people experiencing certain types of:
- stress urinary incontinence (leaking with coughing, sneezing or exercise)
- reduced pelvic floor strength after pregnancy
- some cases of pelvic organ prolapse
- recovery after certain surgeries.
Even then, the exercises should be tailored to your individual needs rather than copied from an app or social media video.
How do you know if your pelvic floor is weak or tight?
The short answer is—you can't tell based on symptoms alone. Many symptoms overlap.
For example, both weak and overactive pelvic floor muscles can contribute to:
- bladder leakage
- urinary urgency
- pelvic discomfort
- feelings of pelvic heaviness.
That's why an assessment with a pelvic floor physiotherapist is so valuable.
Rather than guessing, they'll assess how your muscles:
- contract
- relax
- coordinate
- respond during movement
- work alongside your breathing and core.
From there, they can develop a treatment plan that's specific to your body and your goals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can Kegels make pelvic pain worse?
Yes. If your pelvic floor muscles are already overactive or unable to relax properly, repeatedly contracting them may increase tension and aggravate symptoms. An assessment can help determine whether strengthening, relaxation, or a combination of both is appropriate.
Should I stop doing Kegels if they hurt?
Pelvic floor exercises shouldn't be painful. If they cause discomfort or worsen your symptoms, stop the exercises and seek advice from a pelvic floor physiotherapist.
Are Kegels bad?
Not at all. Kegels are an effective treatment for many people—but only when they're prescribed for the right reason. Like any exercise, they work best when they're matched to the individual rather than applied as a universal solution.
The Bottom Line
Kegels can be incredibly effective—but they're not the answer to every pelvic floor problem. If you've been doing pelvic floor exercises without improvement, or you're experiencing pelvic pain, painful intercourse, constipation or difficulty emptying your bladder, your muscles may need a different approach.
A pelvic floor physiotherapist can assess exactly how your muscles are functioning and develop a treatment plan that's tailored to your needs—not just your symptoms.
Don't guess whether you should be doing Kegels. If your symptoms aren't improving, book a pelvic floor assessment and find out what your body really needs.
More from the blog






